Successful City Council hearing leads to pending end to ICE holds, deportation requests

Community-Led Coalition Calls for an End to All ICE Holds

Philadelphia—On Wednesday, March 12th, City Council held a historic public hearing on Philadelphia’s compliance with ICE holds, which are non-mandatory requests from the federal immigration enforcement office to local Philadelphia law enforcement to hold someone who should otherwise be released. Immigrant leaders, advocates, and allies took the stand before Council’s Public Safety Committee to discuss the devastating impact of ICE holds on immigrant communities in Philadelphia and to call on the Mayor to work with community organizations to draft a new policy that ends all ICE holds.

“We have an opportunity here to sit on the side of hope, of love and of justice by creating a policy that does not create divisions among our families, one that can begin to rebuild trust between local police and the community and one that will ultimately create a better Philadelphia for all us,” said Executive Director of Juntos, Erika Almiron.

In testimony presented during the hearing, Director of Public Safety Michael Resnick announced that the Mayor is drafting a policy that would end the majority of ICE holds in Philadelphia. The Philadelphia Family Unity Network (PFUN)  welcomes the Mayor’s initiative in drafting this policy, which would be a huge step forward for the city of Philadelphia, and is grateful for recent opportunities to meet with officials from the Mayor’s administration to provide input on the devastating impact of ICE holds on immigrant communities.

According to Director Resnick, the proposed policy has not yet been finalized and “the administration is still open to discussion,” an announcement that was met with cheers from the audience in the hearing. Following the hearing, PFUN invited the Mayor’s office to meet with the coalition in the coming weeks to discuss concerns that remain about the proposed policy.  As it stands, the policy would continue to use ICE holds against some individuals based on their criminal history.  This type of complicated carve-out contradicts the city’s stance on redemption and rehabilitation for individuals leaving prison, creates confusion and mistakes in the implementation of the policy, and subjects the city to costly liability for unjustified imprisonment. Constitutional concerns with ICE holds will continue even if only one ICE hold remains. “The collaboration between local police and ICE has resulted in fear and distrust in immigrant communities and led to the perception that local police are actively seeking to enforce federal immigration laws. The proposed policy will also continue to send a message to immigrant communities that asking for police protection could subject them or those that they care about to deportation”, said Tasha Kelemen, Executive Director of the Pennsylvania Immigration and Citizenship Coalition (PICC).

Members of PFUN have been involved in ongoing work with the city for a number of years about the possibility of enacting a policy that would end ICE holds and begin to intervene in the  mass deportation of Philadelphia residents. “In our experience of doing work in coalition, we’ve found that policies often divide immigrant communities along lines of legal status, economic status, education, criminal history, gender identity, sexual orientation, family structure, and marital status, as well as other categories. We have worked hard in Philadelphia to build across communities innovatively in the face of these divisions to create a more understanding and collaborative immigrant community in the city,” said Mia-lia Kiernan, community organizer with 1Love Movement.

PFUN continues to ask the Mayor to adopt a policy that reflects the work that has been done to bridge differences between communities, and honors our City’s stance on rehabilitation, re-entry and second chances. The coalition is inviting Mayor Nutter to meet with immigrant leaders and community members to listen to concerns about the harm caused by divisive policies before taking further action on his proposed executive order. “Immigrants must have a place at the negotiation table with the Nutter Administration to express how ICE holds devastate our families and communities every day and to create a better policy,” says New Sanctuary Movement community organizer Blanca Pacheco.

PFUN would like to thank the following organizations for supporting the long campaign that led to this historic day and for ensuring that a new policy on ICE holds reflects the experiences of Philadelphia’s immigrant communities: AFRICOM, ACANA, American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania, American Friends Service Committee (AFSC) of Newark, Asian Americans United, Boat People SOS Delaware Valley, Concilio, Congreso de Latinos Unidos, Council on American Islamic Relations, Coalition of Labor Union Women, FAVOR International, Fight for Drivers Licenses, HIAS Pennsylvania, Media Mobilizing Project, National Day Laborer Organizing Network (NDLON), The Philadelphia Student Union, Women Organized Against Rape and other organizations across the city

——————————————————————

PFUN members: 1Love Movement, JUNTOS, New Sanctuary Movement of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Immigration and Citizenship Coalition, and Victim/Witness Services of South Philadelphia.

Previous slide
Next slide

Immigrant led Community Organizing

Our staff manages our campaigns and programs while our members join our working committees to inform our programming, choose our campaigns, and plan our strategies to win. Through conversation and listening, our members and the community on the ground are the ones directing the organization. When people reach out to NSM, they connect with someone who speaks their language, looks like them, and is committed to empowering immigrant communities because they understand their journey and struggle. At NSM, our communities see their peers guiding our mission, creating trust, and allowing members to recognize NSM as an immigrant-led organization.
NSM works to lift the skills of the affected community and dismantle systems of oppression while promoting systems of mutual support, collective liberation, and respect for all people, which is why we provide interpretation services, respect childcare needs, schedule our sessions during times that work best for members who work multiple jobs or cannot meet in person, and allow members to inform us about their individual needs before meetings.
The community leads our work at every level to eliminate unnecessary barriers and meet the varied needs of our members.

Leadership Development

Our Leadership Development Program is a step in recruiting and training new leaders and training. The program blends the skills and experiences members bring from their home countries with NSM’s signature faith-rooted and anti-racist organizing model.

We have curricula for each level of membership, which includes workshops on the history of detention, community organizing, nonviolent protest, campaign strategy, and ongoing anti-racism training. Our programming encourages immigrant leaders to find their voice, understand the power of collective resistance, and join a community of immigrant leaders fighting for transformational systemic changes rooted in social and economic justice.

Leading this initiative is Bertha Murcia, one of NSM's Community Organizers. She is an alumna of NSM’s Promotoras de Justicia immigrant leadership program and oversees member engagement.

Build Community Power

NSM’s organizing efforts emphasize community building, inviting people to new roles, deepening Black and Brown solidarity, long-term leadership development, and impactful campaigns.

We build a base of people from our 33 congregations and Accompaniment Team and direct that people-power to fight specific campaigns. Staff members work with immigrant members to choose our campaigns, guide our strategies, lead events, and ensure our work is focused on meeting the needs of Philadelphia’s various immigrant communities.

Having a hands-on role in changing policy allows our members to gain a sense of empowerment, confidence, and self-respect. Empowering immigrants of color to organize collectively is part of NSM’s long haul work to create a people-powered movement for immigrant justice.